FlowsBook a callSign inCreate free accountSign up
Site selection and expansion

When to say no to a site: walk-away rules to set before you view it

Most bad leases are signed after a good viewing. Set the reasons you would walk away before you see a site, and let location data check them for every candidate.

Part of the guide AI employee for site selection

By the xMap team · · 5 min read

Say no to a site when it fails a rule you wrote down before you saw it: too many strong competitors within reach, too few people for each of them, a street where businesses keep closing, an area that is quiet at the hours you trade, or roads that make it hard to get to. Writing the rules first matters because a site visit is persuasive. The unit is bright, the agent is friendly, the deadline is Friday, and a list of numbers you agreed on last month is the only thing that argues back.

This article is for owners and expansion teams who look at more sites than they open. It covers why walk-away rules work, the six most useful ones, how to set the thresholds, a worked example, and an AI employee that checks every candidate against them before anyone books a viewing.

Why decide the reasons to walk away first

Site decisions suffer from a familiar problem: once you have spent a morning at a site, met the landlord and pictured your sign above the door, you look for reasons to say yes. Data gathered after that point tends to be read kindly. A rule set in advance, such as no more than eight direct competitors within a 10-minute walk, does not care how nice the shopfront looked.

Walk-away rules also save time. If most candidates can be ruled out from a desk, the team's viewings go to the few that deserve them.

Six walk-away rules that location data can check

1. Too many strong competitors close by

Count the places of your kind within the distance customers will travel, and look at their ratings. Ten competitors averaging 3.6 is a different market from ten averaging 4.7. Nearby places gives the count, the nearest one, the average rating and how many belong to chains, for each candidate.

2. Too few people for each competitor

Divide the residents around the site by the number of competitors. Where xMap has population figures (among them France, Canada, India, Thailand, Egypt and Australia, not the United Kingdom or the United States), Demographics gives the residents; elsewhere, use homes and workplaces nearby as a guide.

3. A street where businesses keep closing

A high street where several units of every kind are marked closed is telling you something about rents, access or footfall that a single viewing will not. Search all kinds of place within 200 m and count how many are listed as closed.

4. Quiet at the hours you trade

Mobility Footfall gives footfall per day as people-hours of presence and the busiest hour and day, in the cities it covers. A breakfast business whose candidate street peaks at nine in the evening should think twice. The figures arrive about ten days after the day they describe and measure presence, not shoppers.

5. Hard to reach at the hours that matter

Traffic Flow gives the live speed and a jam factor on the roads around each site; read it at your busiest hours over a couple of weeks. It does not count cars. Traffic incidents shows closures and roadworks nearby, which can turn a good site into a building site for a season.

6. Your own branch already serves it

If a candidate sits within a short drive of one of your own stores, it may move customers rather than win new ones. Draw a Travel area around each and see how much they overlap.

Setting the thresholds

The numbers in a rule should come from your own best and worst sites, not from someone else's rule of thumb. Run the same checks on the branches you already have, then set each threshold a little worse than your weakest good branch. If your best-performing shop has twelve competitors within a 10-minute walk and still thrives, a rule of eight is too strict for you; if your weakest closed with six, eight may be about right.

A worked example: a yoga studio group in Melbourne

This example is made up. A group of four yoga studios in Melbourne is offered five units. Before booking viewings, its founder writes three hard rules from her existing studios and two soft ones:

  • Hard: no more than six yoga or pilates studios within 1 km; at least 6,000 residents per studio within 2 km; under a quarter of listed places within 200 m marked closed.
  • Soft: footfall in the area busiest before nine or after five; no long roadworks nearby in the coming months.

The checks run on all five units in an afternoon. Two fail a hard rule: one has nine studios within a kilometre, another sits on a block where a third of the listed businesses are closed. One passes everything. Two pass the hard rules with one soft fail each, which become questions for the agent. Three viewings instead of five, and the founder walks into each with the numbers in her pocket.

How to do it with an AI employee

Upload the candidates and let one flow check every rule:

  1. My data: the candidate sites, and in a second table your existing branches for comparison.
  2. Nearby places: your kind of business, each incoming place with counts, within your distance.
  3. Demographics: residents within your distance, where figures exist.
  4. Mobility Footfall: the busiest hour and day, where measured.
  5. Calculated field: people per competitor, and a pass or fail for each rule.
  6. Branch: sites that fail a hard rule go one way, the rest the other.
  7. Email: the passes, with their soft fails as questions, and the fails with the rule they broke.

What lands in the inbox is a verdict per site in plain words, with the figure behind each rule, so anyone can see why a site was ruled out. For two or three survivors, Compare sites puts them side by side on the same measures. The Competitor density around each site and Where to open next templates start from these checks.

Questions

How many walk-away rules should I have?

Three to six. Fewer and important risks slip through; more and every site fails something, so people start ignoring the rules.

What if a site fails a rule but the deal is very good?

Write down why you are breaking the rule and what you expect instead. Then check, six months after opening, whether the exception paid off. That is how rules get better.

Can the data tell me the rent is too high?

No. xMap Flows has no rent data. It can tell you whether the area around a site has the people, the competition and the access to support the rent you are offered.

Are these rules the same for every kind of business?

The kinds of rule are; the thresholds are not. Set them from your own branches, because a gym, a bakery and a clinic live with very different numbers.

Templates that do this

Read next

More on site selection and expansion · Every article · Templates

Put it to work

An AI employee in xMap Flows does this on live data, on its own timetable. Start from a template or describe it in plain words.