FlowsBook a callSign inCreate free accountSign up
Site selection and expansion

How to compare two locations for a business when both look good

To compare two locations for a business fairly, ask one clear question, measure both the same way, then weigh what the numbers cannot see. A method and an example.

Part of the guide AI employee for site selection

By the xMap team · · 5 min read

To compare two locations for a business, first write down the one question the choice turns on ("which unit will more people who need a pharmacy reach easily?"), then measure both spots the same way: the same walking or driving distance, the same kind of competitor, the same hour for the roads. Lay the figures side by side, see which lines really differ, and only then bring in what numbers cannot show, such as rent, the landlord and the unit itself. Most two-way choices are decided by one or two lines where the gap is large; the rest is noise.

This is for owners and managers choosing between two units, plots or neighbourhoods: a clinic, a pharmacy, a gym, a showroom, a restaurant. It covers framing the question, what to measure, how to read a close result, a made-up choice in Mumbai, and the shortcut of asking for the comparison in plain words.

Frame the question before you measure

Two locations can be compared on dozens of things, and a long table invites you to count wins instead of thinking. Decide what the business lives on first.

  • Walk-in trade (a pharmacy, a cafe, a phone shop): people within a short walk, anchors that bring them past, rivals close by.
  • Destination trade (a gym, a specialist clinic, a furniture showroom): people within a short drive, ease of getting there at the busy hours, rivals across a wider area.
  • Service from the site (a delivery kitchen, a repair van base): how far you can reach in a set time, and the roads you leave by.

Then pick the distance your customers really travel and use it for both spots. Comparing a 1 km circle around one with a 10-minute drive around the other is the most common way to get the wrong answer.

What to measure for each spot

  1. People. Residents within the reach, in countries with population data (France, Canada, India, Egypt, Thailand and Australia among them; not the United Kingdom or the United States).
  2. People per competitor. Residents divided by the number of rivals in the same reach. It often separates two spots better than either count alone.
  3. Competitors and their quality. How many, how many are chains, and their average rating. Weakly rated rivals are an opening; strong ones are a fight.
  4. Openings in the last year. A spot where rivals keep opening is getting crowded, or getting popular. Look at which.
  5. Getting there. Live road speed and congestion near each spot at the hour you would be busiest, and charging points if your customers drive electric cars.

Reading a close result

Often the two spots come out within a few percent on most lines. That is an answer too: the data says the choice will be decided by something else. In that case look at the one or two lines with a real gap, and then at what no dataset holds: the rent and the length of the lease, the frontage and the turn in from the road, whether the landlord is redeveloping the block, and how the street feels at 8 in the morning and 7 at night. If those do not separate the two either, take the cheaper lease and keep the money for opening well.

A made-up example in Mumbai

This example is made up. A pharmacist is offered two ground-floor units in Mumbai, one on a residential street in Andheri and one near a suburban rail station. The question: which unit will more households reach on foot for everyday prescriptions?

Measure, 10-minute walkResidential streetNear the station
Residents58,00061,000
Pharmacies614
People per pharmacy9,7004,400
Clinics within 500 m35
Average rival rating4.04.4

Made-up figures to show the reasoning.

The resident counts are close, so that line decides nothing. People per pharmacy is more than twice as high on the residential street, and its rivals are rated lower. The station unit has more clinics nearby, which brings prescriptions, but fourteen well-rated pharmacies already serve them. The pharmacist chooses the residential street, after checking that the unit is on the side of the road with the morning school walk.

Getting the comparison in a few minutes

In xMap Flows, Compare sites measures two or three spots the same way and lays them out in one table, the best value of each line marked only when the values really differ, with a short verdict that uses only the figures in the table. You can start it from the map (drop a pin on each spot) or by asking Ask xMap in plain words, for example "compare 12 Main Street and the station plaza for a pharmacy". The price is shown before anything runs, and figures that are estimates or sample data are labelled. It uses a fixed reach (a 10-minute drive for people, 1 km for rivals); for a walking reach like the one above, build the same measures in a flow. Behind it are the same blocks you can put in a flow: Travel area, Demographics, Nearby places, Traffic Flow and EV charging.

If you compare locations often, for example every unit an agent sends, an AI employee can do it for each new row in a sheet and email the table. The site selection guide describes that set-up, and the template where to open next is a good starting point; site advisor chat for the expansion team lets colleagues ask for comparisons in a chat.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Different reach for each spot. Same distance, same mode of travel, or the comparison is meaningless.
  • Counting wins. Seven small wins do not beat one large gap on the line your business lives on.
  • Measuring the roads at different times. A road at noon and a road at 18:00 are different roads.
  • Treating a verdict as the decision. It summarises the table. The lease, the unit and your own visit still decide.

Questions

Can I compare more than two locations?

Compare sites takes two or three spots at a time. For a longer list, score them all with the same rules in a flow, then compare the top two or three side by side.

What if the two locations are in different countries?

You can compare them, but population figures exist only in some countries. If one side has none, compare on competitors, anchors and roads only, and say so.

Does the comparison show how many cars pass?

No. It shows live road speed and congestion. Hourly car counts exist only for roads in the United Arab Emirates, through Road traffic history.

Can I share the comparison with a partner?

Yes. A comparison can be downloaded as a PDF or shared by a link that shows the table and the map.

Templates that do this

Read next

More on site selection and expansion · Every article · Templates

Put it to work

An AI employee in xMap Flows does this on live data, on its own timetable. Start from a template or describe it in plain words.