FlowsBook a callSign inCreate free accountSign up
Workflows by industry

How analysts benchmark a brand against its rivals, city by city

Branch counts, share of a market, ratings and recent openings: a repeatable way for investors and consultants to compare one brand with its rivals across several cities.

Part of the guide Workflow automation

By the xMap team · · 5 min read

Analysts benchmark a brand against its rivals by counting each brand's branches inside the same area of every city, setting those counts against the whole market there, and comparing ratings and recent openings. Four figures per brand per city do most of the work: branches, share of the places of that kind, average rating, and branches opened in the last year. Laid side by side, they show where a brand leads, where it is thin, and whether it is growing faster or slower than the others.

This piece is for analysts at investment firms, strategy consultants and corporate development teams preparing a deal memo, a market entry case or a portfolio review. It covers how to set up a fair comparison, a worked example built on real counts from xMap's places database, the traps that skew a benchmark, and an AI employee that keeps the comparison current.

Set up the comparison so it is fair

Most benchmarking errors come from comparing different things. Before counting anything, fix three choices and keep them the same for every city.

  • The same area. A fixed circle from the city centre (for example 10 km), or the same administrative boundary, for every city. Comparing a brand's count in a whole metro area with a rival's count in the centre only is meaningless.
  • The same kind of place. Gyms against gyms, bakeries against bakeries. If a brand runs both small studios and large clubs, decide whether both count.
  • The same date. Branch counts move. Run every city in the same week and say when.

The Nearby places block works well for this: one search per type of place per area, with a setting to keep only one brand when you want a brand's own count, or every place when you want the market. The Area of interest block sets the cities and the distance.

A worked example with real counts

Take gyms in three cities, using xMap's places database for November 2026 and a 10 km circle around each city centre.

CityGyms listedCounted for chainsIn a chainLargest chain's branchesAverage rating
Toronto24624672234.6
London1,112353 nearest the centre88204.5
Sydney692347 nearest the centre82154.6

Gyms within 10 km of each city centre, xMap's places database, November 2026. In London and Sydney the chain figures and the largest chain's branches are of the gyms nearest the centre, not of every gym listed.

Read carefully, the table already says something. In Toronto every gym listed was counted, and the largest chain holds 23 of the 246, a little under one in ten. In London and Sydney the chain figures cover only the gyms nearest the centre, so the largest chain's 20 and 15 branches are a share of 353 and 347, not of the full totals. That is the right way to quote them, and it is the first trap in any benchmark: never divide a figure from a sample by a figure from the whole.

Now add a brand of your own. Say, as a made-up case, that the brand you are studying has 9 branches in the Toronto circle, 11 in the London sample and 4 in the Sydney sample. Its share is about 4% in Toronto (9 of 246), about 3% of the London sample and about 1% of the Sydney sample. Against the largest chain in each city it is less than half the size in Toronto and London, and well under a third in Sydney. If its average rating is also below the city average, the case for growth there is weak; if it is above, the brand may be small but liked, which is a different story.

The figures that matter beyond counts

  • Recent openings. Branches with an opening date in the last twelve months show momentum. Opening dates are missing for many places, so treat this as a signal, not a census.
  • Ratings and review counts. A brand rated well above the market with plenty of reviews has a reputation to build on. A high rating from five reviews means little.
  • Where branches sit. Mapping the branches shows whether a brand clusters in the centre or spreads to the suburbs, and where a rival is present and it is not.
  • Closures. A branch that disappears between two runs is as telling as one that opens.

Traps that skew a benchmark

  • Name variants. Brands appear under slightly different names, with a franchisee's name, or with a location added. Check the brand filter catches them all, and look at the list, not just the count.
  • Mixing samples and totals. As above, quote shares of the same base.
  • The centre effect. A circle around the centre favours brands that cluster downtown. If a brand is suburban by design, use a wider area or a ring.
  • One snapshot. A single count is a position, not a trend. Repeat the run monthly and compare.
  • Reading too much into small numbers. A difference of two branches is noise in a market of a thousand.

Doing it with an AI employee

An AI employee can run the same comparison every month and send the analyst a short note on what moved.

  1. Schedule on the first Monday of the month.
  2. Area of interest with the cities, each as a 10 km circle from its centre.
  3. Nearby places for the type of place, once for the whole market and once per brand you track, with Only this brand set.
  4. Calculated field to work out each brand's share of the market in each city.
  5. xMap LLM on the whole list, told to compare the brands city by city, using only the figures given.
  6. Make a report to turn it into a PDF with tables and a map, emailed to the deal team.

The analyst opens a monthly report with branch counts, shares, ratings and openings per brand per city, and a paragraph on what changed since the last one. The templates My brand against two rivals, city by city, Chains against independents, city by city and Ratings of my portfolio companies' branches are close starting points.

Questions

Can I count only one brand's branches?

Yes. Nearby places has a setting to keep only places whose brand or name has the words you give, and a setting to cover a whole city area in several searches so branches across it are found.

How do I compare cities of very different sizes?

Compare shares and ratios rather than raw counts: a brand's share of the places of its kind, or branches per hundred places, within the same size of area in each city.

Why do some figures cover only the places nearest the centre?

In large markets the chain, rating and opening figures are worked out from the places nearest the centre. Quote them as a share of that group, never of the full total.

Can the comparison run every month on its own?

Yes. Deploy the flow on a monthly schedule and the report arrives by email, with the same areas and types each time so months can be compared.

Templates that do this

Read next

More on workflows by industry · Every article · Templates

Put it to work

An AI employee in xMap Flows does this on live data, on its own timetable. Start from a template or describe it in plain words.