FlowsBook a callSign inCreate free accountSign up
Population and demographics

How to weigh population against competition when judging an area

More people is good, more rivals is bad, but by how much? A plain method to balance residents and competitors, with people per rival, a scoring grid and a worked example.

Part of the guide Location intelligence automation

By the xMap team · · 5 min read

To weigh population against competition, divide the people who live within reach of a site by the number of rivals inside the same area. That ratio, people per rival, is the simplest fair measure: it rises when an area has more residents and falls when it has more competitors. Use it to rank areas first, then adjust for the things the ratio cannot see, such as how good the rivals are, how much the residents spend and whether visitors and workers add trade on top of the people who sleep there.

This guide is for anyone deciding where to open, expand or advertise: shop owners, franchise developers, clinic groups, gym operators and the analysts who advise them. It covers the basic ratio, when to weight it, a worked example, the mistakes that make a crowded area look empty, and an AI employee that works it out for a list of places.

Why neither number works alone

A big population on its own invites the wrong move: the busiest districts usually have the most competitors, and a new arrival there fights for a thin slice. A low competitor count on its own is just as misleading: an area can be empty of rivals because nobody lives there, or because the people who do are not your customers. The two only mean something together, and only when both are counted inside the same boundary.

The basic ratio, and how to make it fair

  1. Draw the area customers will travel from: a travel area by car, on foot or by bike, rather than a circle, so rivers and motorways are respected.
  2. Count the residents inside it. Where it matters, count only the age groups you serve: children for a tutoring centre, adults for a gym, residents aged 60 and over for a hearing clinic.
  3. Count the rivals inside the same area, of the same kind as you.
  4. Divide residents by rivals. Add one to the rival count first, counting yourself, so an area with no rivals does not divide by zero and the figure reads as people per place once you open.

In xMap Flows, the Travel area block draws the area, the Demographics block counts residents and their nine age groups inside it, and Nearby places counts rivals of the kinds you pick from xMap's places database. A Calculated field then works out the ratio.

When to weight the ratio

People per rival treats every rival as equal. They rarely are. Three adjustments cover most cases:

  • Rival strength. A rival rated 4.8 with hundreds of reviews takes more custom than one rated 3.2 with a handful. Count strong rivals as more than one, for example as 1.5.
  • Chains and independents. A chain branch has a brand, marketing and often lower prices; independents vary. Decide which you fear more and weight accordingly.
  • Distance. A rival at your door matters more than one at the edge of the area. A simple rule: count rivals within a short walk twice.

Keep the weights simple and write them down. A grid that nobody can explain will not survive a board meeting.

A worked example

Here is an invented comparison of three candidate areas for a physiotherapy practice in Melbourne. The resident counts are adults aged 20 and over inside a 10-minute drive; the rival counts are physiotherapy practices inside the same areas.

AreaAdults insideRivalsStrong rivals (4.7+, many reviews)People per rivalWeighted
Inner north92,000148about 6,100about 4,800
Eastern suburb61,00051about 10,200about 9,400
Bayside48,00065about 6,900about 5,000

Made-up figures for illustration. People per rival counts the new practice as one more place; weighted counts strong rivals as 1.5.

The inner north has the most people but also the most competition, and its strong rivals pull the weighted figure down further. Bayside looks reasonable on raw numbers, but five of its six rivals are well rated, so the weighted figure drops. The eastern suburb has fewer people but far fewer rivals, and only one strong one: it comes out on top in both columns. The next check would be whether its residents travel elsewhere for health services, and what rents look like.

Mistakes to avoid

  • Different boundaries for the two counts. Residents of a district against rivals in a circle gives a number that means nothing.
  • Total population when you serve one group. A district full of retired people is not a strong market for a children's swim school.
  • Forgetting daytime trade. Offices, stations and shopping streets bring people who live elsewhere. For a lunchtime business, residents are only half the story; footfall data helps here.
  • Over-precise weights. Weights of 1.37 and 0.82 suggest a precision the data does not have. Use round numbers.
  • Reading a high ratio as a guarantee. An area may lack rivals because a previous one failed there. Check what closed.

Doing it with an AI employee

An AI employee can work out people per rival for every candidate address and rank them.

  1. Put the candidate addresses in My data.
  2. Add Travel area, for example 10 minutes by car.
  3. Add Demographics for residents and age groups inside each area.
  4. Add Nearby places for your rivals, set to pass on each address with the counts and the average rating of what it found.
  5. Add Calculated field lines for people per rival and the weighted figure.
  6. Add Sort and limit by the weighted figure, then Email the ranked list with a map.

The ranked list lands in the inbox with every figure behind each rank, so the reasoning can be checked. For a broader view of a city, the templates Competitor density around each site and Where children are far from a paediatrician apply the same idea at scale.

Questions

What is a good number of people per competitor?

There is no universal figure; it depends on how often people buy and how far they travel. Compare areas against each other, and against areas where your existing sites do well.

Should I count chains and independents the same?

Start by counting them equally, then weight whichever you find harder to compete with. Write the weights down so others can follow them.

What if population figures are not available in my country?

Use other measures of demand inside the same area, such as homes, schools, offices or footfall, and compare them with the rival count.

Does a high ratio mean I will succeed?

No. It means demand per competitor looks high on paper. Check rents, access, what closed there before and how strong the nearest rivals are.

Templates that do this

Read next

More on population and demographics · Every article · Templates

Put it to work

An AI employee in xMap Flows does this on live data, on its own timetable. Start from a template or describe it in plain words.